How we can work together →

Shopify Consultant

Plan and scale growth for your Shopify store

Fractional Ecommerce Director

Ongoing leadership for next-stage ecommerce growth

Ecommerce Consultant

Hired to solve specific growth challenges

Ecommerce Coaching

1-2-1 mentoring for founders and ecommerce leaders

Conversion Strategy

How to convert more visitors into buyers

Retention Strategy

Grow your ecommerce business on repeat

SEO & GEO Consultant

Become the answer in Google and AI search

1-Day Ecommerce Growth Blueprint

One focused day to map your next stage of growth

Replatform to Shopify

Build your growth machine right from day one

Testimonials

What founders say about working together

Not sure which fits? Let’s talk it through.

“Working with Ian is probably the best thing that has happened to us in the last 6 years.”

Rivki Stoll · Private White VC

Data →

Ecomonomics

The numbers behind your ecommerce growth

Attribution and measurement

Know what is really driving your sales

Technology →

Tools and martech

The tools that power modern ecommerce growth

SEO and AI visibility

Get found in search and in AI answers

Affiliates and partnerships

Collaborations, partnerships and affiliate programmes

Human touch →

Brand and positioning

The insight and stories that make your brand matter

Retention and subscriptions

Growing profitable repeat business

Content and community

Copy, stories and community that build connection

New lessons every weekday · 100s of articles, written by me, not a robot

Explore all growth lessons →

Retailers, don’t suffer from email repetition syndrome this holiday season

An email newsletter subscriber is for life. Not just for Christmas.

That’s what you have to tell yourself the next time you click the ‘SEND CAMPAIGN’ button.

It’s that time of year when retail websites suddenly want to know us (the poor unsuspecting email recipients) again. Just this week, Superdrug (who for the life of me I can never remember shopping online with….) tempted me to ‘perfect those locks’ as I got ready for party season. Oh, Superdrug, you really don’t know me do you?

Examples of email newsletters with poor context

For all the wonderment of the Christmas season, our inboxes should be prepared for the annual hammering of ill thought-out SHOW ME YOUR MONEY! newsletters.

OH LOOK. A FREE DELIVER OFFER.

There’s the good side of retailer email marketing. The side where you know consideration and structure has gone into the campaign. Where the retailer has something genuine and interesting to share. Where it’s context over personalisation and data interrogation means that I won’t be subjected to newsletters like the one highlighted above.

Then there’s the ugly side. The side where revenue targets are increased by 100% (because it’s Christmas) and digital marketing teams look to their arsenal of assets. Eyes widen as they dust off the customer database to find an extra 20,000 email addresses just ready to be targetted. You can picture the scenario can’t you? You can’t? Well, maybe the image below will help:

Poorly devised marketing strategy

That’s right. 100% approval to absolutely hammer the customer database into buying submission. Another bout of RFDOS (Repetitive Free Deliver Offer Syndrome) is about to hit the nation. And this year it’s going to be even more painful than the last.

I’m not sure of the rationale. Maybe there’s a general consensus that consumers are going to be hit so hard with email tripe that we simply won’t cope with the pain. Maybe we’ll no longer have the energy to point our cursors to the unsubscribe button? Maybe we’ll be unforgiving. I mean, it is the holiday season right?

THE ‘OH BOLLOCKS, LET’S TRY EVERYTHING APPROACH’

Variety isn’t the spice of email campaigns. Consistency is. Yes, I like consistency. Consistently providing your newsletter recipients with fresh meaningful and inspirational shopping ideas. Ideas relating to who (are you hearing me, Superdrug?) your audience are and what matters to them.

One brand leaves me consistently frustrated with how they market themselves online. Twinings Tea. A brand packed with 300 years of history. A brand with a wide range of variations upon a common theme. Unfortunately, that’s the same formula for their email strategy. A brand, I fear, is too reliant upon it’s established position in the market place to figure out how and why it matters to it’s loyal consumers.

Twinings represents a default brand within an (as yet) non-disrupted marketplace. A brand that should be far from ordinary.

The 3 email campaigns I’ve received in the past few days will tell you otherwise…

3 quick takeaways that any online retailer can learn from:

1.) FLATTERY WON’T GET YOU ANYWHERE

We love a bargain. 20% off a product will incentivise click through and purchase. What I don’t like about the approach Twining took below was the banner ‘we miss you’. What they are saying is ‘we miss you purchasing from us’. The bizarre thing is, Twinings, I am purchasing from you. Just like a large proportion of your buyers – we buy your products alongside the rest of our weekly groceries. No, I haven’t shopped online for awhile (the reason being it was an awful experience). But, I am still a customer. Don’t miss me when I haven’t gone anywhere….

Example of Email Newsletter With Discount Code

2.) HAVE SOMETHING GENUINE AND OF VALUE TO SHARE

Twinings. A 300 year old brand. So much history to talk about. Such a tremendous story to share. A company that, however, focuses their email subject primarily on ‘selling’. Just 3 hours after I received the email above I was greeted with an email introducing ‘Festive Goodies’. What two senses would you associate with tea? Maybe smell and I don’t know… taste? Well, Twinings are leading their campaign with the vision of colour (black tins with snowflakes):

Example of Email Campaign Without Any Clear Focus

It’s a good tactic to repackage your products for Christmas, don’t get me wrong, but this is yet another ‘sell sell’ campaign from a brand (a 300 year old brand) that should know better.

3.) IT’S NOT ALL ABOUT THE SALE

Email Newsletter Fail

Shop now? Twinings introduce 3 brand new blends and all they can ask us to do is ‘shop now’?

A tea with caramel? Love the idea or hate the idea, there’s a story to be told there surely? Does the image of a resealable tea package really get the taste buds tingling?

With just a little creative flair this series of emails could be turned into a brilliant introduction to the new range of tea flavours.

I don’t understand why Twinings’ email campaign is all about the sale. Their products are on the shelves of supermarkets to local shops across the country. They’re an institution. Surely the introduction of new blends deserves a little better treatment? Especially considering that the ‘shop now’ button relates to our product purchasing online as well as offline…. i.e. picking up a packet of tea during our next weekly shop or dropping a couple of boxes into our Ocado online shopping cart?

Online success for Twinings should not be measured by the sale of products ONLINE. Would you hazard a guess that the sole reason the emails are being sent in the first place is to generate direct revenue? The opportunity Twinings has to reach it’s audience through email is immense. It’s a hugely popular brand. A brand that appears to focus all it’s online attention on selling rather that creating interest above and beyond the £ sign.

The opportunity to reach your most valued customers (those that actually say ‘Yes!’ you can invade our email inbox) should be viewed as a privilege rather than a task.

Take a look through the last dozen or so subjects from Twinings’ email campaign:

Repetitive Email Syndrome

It’s all about the money. Savings…. Discounts… Free Delivery.

Where’s the focus on what really matters to a loyal consumer? It’s a safe bet your local supermarket is selling Twinings cheaper than Twinings’ own online store. Are we really incentivised by a free delivery offer?

Email repetition becomes very taxing for the recipient. At best we ignore, at worst we unsubscribe.

Retailers, why not blend some valuable ingredients into your Christmas email campaigns this year?

  • Theme your email campaigns around product categories you know would be of interest to your reader (based on previous buying habits)
  • Take us behind the scenes as you prepare for Christmas (the ideas behind this year’s range)

I don’t know, go crazy and ask your audience to leave out a cup of Twinings for Santa on Christmas Eve. Take the conversation onto social channels. Ask me what my favourite (non-alcoholic) drink is this season… What’s the most seasonal brew on the Twinings’ product line this December? Maybe shoot a video with a 300-year old variation on the Coca-Cola ‘holidays are coming’ replacing delivery trucks with the old horse and cart. Something fun. Something festive. Something that’s not ‘Hey, wanna cuppa tea? buy one now’.


Free book

Liked this? There are 30 more where that came from.

Make What You Make Matter. 30 lessons in ecommerce growth, written on the shop floor long before AI showed up. Read every chapter free, or take the PDF with you.

Read the book freeGet the PDF

Manage The Machine

Get My Weekly Ecommerce Growth Newsletter (Insights & Tutorials)

Let the machine do the grunt work, so you can focus on the human work of making what you make matter. Straight from my client work. Written by me, not a robot. What does Manage The Machine mean?

Free. Every Monday at 9am. Unsubscribe any time.

Ian Rhodes

Written by EcommerceGrowth.com Founder – Ian Rhodes

Independent Ecommerce Consultant & Coach and author of Make What You Make Matter, with 28 years of ecommerce leadership and 750+ brands worked with. Hired to prioritise and lead the work that delivers next stage growth.

More Ecommerce Growth Lessons and How-To Guides