How we can work together →

Shopify Consultant

Plan and scale growth for your Shopify store

Fractional Ecommerce Director

Ongoing leadership for next-stage ecommerce growth

Ecommerce Consultant

Hired to solve specific growth challenges

Ecommerce Coaching

1-2-1 mentoring for founders and ecommerce leaders

Conversion Strategy

How to convert more visitors into buyers

Retention Strategy

Grow your ecommerce business on repeat

SEO & GEO Consultant

Become the answer in Google and AI search

1-Day Ecommerce Growth Blueprint

One focused day to map your next stage of growth

Replatform to Shopify

Build your growth machine right from day one

Testimonials

What founders say about working together

Not sure which fits? Let’s talk it through.

“Working with Ian is probably the best thing that has happened to us in the last 6 years.”

Rivki Stoll · Private White VC

Data →

Ecomonomics

The numbers behind your ecommerce growth

Attribution and measurement

Know what is really driving your sales

Technology →

Tools and martech

The tools that power modern ecommerce growth

SEO and AI visibility

Get found in search and in AI answers

Affiliates and partnerships

Collaborations, partnerships and affiliate programmes

Human touch →

Brand and positioning

The insight and stories that make your brand matter

Retention and subscriptions

Growing profitable repeat business

Content and community

Copy, stories and community that build connection

New lessons every weekday · 100s of articles, written by me, not a robot

Explore all growth lessons →

Part Five: Grow The Basket

We Haven’t Talked About Retention (Yet)

Don’t let the data alone tell you who comes back.

By Ian Rhodes · Independent Ecommerce Consultant & Coach

A market trader among his fruit and vegetables

Customer retention became all the rage in the ecommerce world a few years back. Funny how nobody seemed to know it existed before 2021.

I bought the domain retention.co.uk a few years ago for less than £1k. I was presenting my keynote, brilliantly entitled ‘Your Retention Please’ (see what I did there?) countering the other speaker’s decks focused on Facebook Ads and growth hacks. So, it seemed a suitable domain. I’ve just turned down 5 figures for the domain. I guess retention is a big deal.

Retention has always been a big deal. It’s just rarely discussed for 3 reasons;

  • It’s difficult to view as it happens post-sale
  • It’s difficult to analyse because the data is all over the place.
  • Agencies rarely push retention as there are no direct costs (eg. ad spend) to justify against revenue earned.

Don’t make this mistake.

I was working with a brand that pushed 25% discount codes for first time purchases. Their business model was based on retention. Give a great post-purchase experience and a great product… folks will come back for more.

That should be the simple premise for a great retention strategy right?

This brand was struggling.

Nobody was coming back to make a purchase. Acquisition was working great… but they just couldn’t turn the dial on repeat business.

My job was to figure out why.

And the issue became clear pretty quickly.

Take a quick walk with me in your consumer shoes. You’re given a 25% discount code that is only available to first time purchasers. What do you do? Of course you do, you register with a different email address and use that code again.

Using that code with a different email address registers you as a brand new customer in Shopify.

Retention wasn’t the issue. Tracking retention was.

Retention wasn’t the issue. Tracking retention was.

People were coming back in their droves to make a second purchase. It’s just that the data was telling them otherwise. And that’s because the data is reliant on the email address to track repeat business.

People were registering again and again using different email addresses. Their work address, their partners address… gmail addresses. We all have access to more than one email account.

Customers learned how to bypass the ‘first purchase only’ requirement. We all do it.

To understand the true retention rate we pulled the data into Excel and filtered by post code.

Now the challenge they face is how to retain customers without the margin-killing 25% discount code being used repeatedly.

Customers aren’t dumb.

My lesson here is not to get too caught up in the numbers. There are wonderful apps that give you a clear view of repeat business metrics, lifetimely.io being one I always work with. Let the data provide you a benchmark to work from. Then focus on the work.

Now go forth and retain.

Try this

Export your orders and match customers by postcode as well as by email address. Compare that repeat rate with the one your dashboard shows you.

Free download

Take the book with you

The full 92-page PDF, free. Pop your email in and I’ll send it straight over. You’ll also get my Manage The Machine newsletter every Monday at 9am: how to let the machine do the grunt work, so you can focus on the human work of making what you make matter. Unsubscribe whenever you like.

You’re already on my list, so here’s your copy: download the PDF.

Can’t see the sign-up box? Your browser may be blocking it. No bother, here’s the book anyway: download the PDF. And if you’d like the Monday newsletter too, sign up here.