Heads up: some links in this post are affiliate links. If you sign up through them I may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. More in my affiliate disclaimer.
Somewhere right now, a YouTuber is filming a review of your competitor’s product.
The affiliate link is in the description. The discount code is pinned in the comments. They’ve said “use my link, it helps the channel” a hundred times.
And they’ve never heard of you.
That’s your next affiliate. They just don’t know it yet. (And neither do you.)
Most Shopify brands I work with have the affiliate software sorted. App installed, commission set, a nice little “Become a partner” link in the footer. Then they wait.
And wait.
A trickle of applications comes in. Half are coupon sites. A couple are friends of the founder. One is a lovely lady with 212 Instagram followers who’s very excited about the 10%.
The programme exists. It just doesn’t do very much.
So this is the approach I keep coming back to with the brands I work with: stop waiting for affiliates to find you, and go and get the ones who are already selling for your competitors.
Recruitment is the bit that breaks
Tracking links isn’t hard any more. Paying commission isn’t hard. Shopify apps have made the plumbing almost boring.
The hard part is recruiting partners who actually activate. Who post. Who sell.
I was on a conference stage in 1999 talking about exactly this problem. You’d think we’d have cracked it by now.
We haven’t. Most brands still recruit the way they did twenty years ago. Google “best [category] blogs”. Scroll Instagram hoping someone looks promising. Join a network and hope somebody notices you. Send cold DMs that never get a reply.
Slow. Manual. Guesswork.
And the real killer? You’ve no idea whether any of these people can sell until you’ve spent weeks building the relationship.
Why your competitors’ affiliates are the ones to go after
So, flip it round.
Instead of looking for people who might be good at selling your product, look for the people already selling something very like it.
They understand your category. They know what your customer worries about, which questions come up in the comments, and which angle gets the click.
They understand the deal. You don’t have to explain what an affiliate link is, how codes work or why commission beats a one-off fee.
They’ve proved it. There’s content sat on the internet right now, with a link in it, sending buyers to a product like yours.
Your competitors have already done half your recruitment for you. They found these people, onboarded them and taught them the category. Bless ’em.
All you need to do is turn up with a better offer, a better product story, or simply be the brand that bothered to say hello.
(And no, this isn’t sneaky. Good affiliates promote several brands in a category. That’s what makes them useful to their audience. Being the second brand in a “best of” list is a perfectly decent place to start.)
They don’t need to be big, either. A niche creator who understands affiliate will often outsell a celebrity asking for a five-figure fee. I wrote about that in why you might be chasing the wrong sized affiliates.
The manual way (and why it falls over)
You can do all of this by hand. I have. It goes something like this:
- Pick three to five competitors.
- Search their names on Google, YouTube, Instagram and TikTok.
- Open every review, every “best X for Y” list, every unboxing.
- Check the links. Is it an affiliate link? Which network?
- Hunt for an email address. Contact page, About page, the YouTube “business enquiries” button, guesswork.
- Write a personal email that references their actual content.
- Log it in a spreadsheet.
- Chase in a week. Then chase again.
Do that for fifty prospects and you’ve lost a fortnight.
Worse, the list goes stale. The creator who reviewed your competitor last month isn’t on it. The TikToker who started covering your niche in October isn’t on it. You export the list once, then slowly work through it for six months while the market moves on without you.
The workflow I use now: AffiliateFinder.ai
This is where AffiliateFinder.ai comes in. It’s the tool I point Shopify brands to for affiliate recruitment.
You give it your brand, your competitors and the topics you care about. It goes off and finds the creators and publishers already promoting those competitors, or making content in your niche, across websites, YouTube, Instagram and TikTok.
Then it does the bits that used to eat the fortnight.
1. Find the people already selling your category
For each prospect you see their content, the competitors they promote and, where it can see them, the affiliate networks they use. You can also run a lookalike search from your best existing partner. “Find me more people like her.” Lovely.
2. Filter out the noise
This is where most lists fall apart, so be ruthless.
Filter by channel and format, because YouTube Shorts and Instagram Reels behave very differently to a 20-minute review. Filter by country traffic and language, so a UK brand isn’t courting a creator whose audience lives mostly in Ohio. And hide the coupon and discount sites if they’re not part of your plan.
(They usually shouldn’t be. Coupon sites are brilliant at taking credit for sales you’d have made anyway. More on that in stopping the coupon code leaks that kill margin.)
3. Get the contact details
It enriches prospects with verified email addresses. No more guessing at hello@, or clicking “business enquiries” on YouTube and hoping for the best.
4. Write outreach that shows you’ve actually watched their stuff
It drafts emails from the creator’s real content: a specific video, review or post. You review and edit before anything goes out, and you set the offer (commission, free product, a paid placement). Then it runs the follow-ups for you, and stops the moment someone replies.
Please do edit the drafts. Put your voice in. A creator can smell a template from three inboxes away.
5. Manage the whole pipeline in one place
Replies land in one inbox, and every prospect sits in a pipeline: saved, contacting, replied, negotiating, in progress.
No spreadsheets. No lost email threads. No forgetting who you contacted three weeks ago.
And you can see how each campaign is doing: opens, replies, and how many prospects make it through to a deal.
6. Let it keep looking
This is the bit I like most. It scans again every week. New content means new prospects, so your list keeps moving instead of rotting in a CSV.
Affiliate discovery becomes a pipeline you keep topping up.
Two extras worth knowing about. If a creator quotes you for a paid YouTube or TikTok placement, the revenue estimator lets you sense-check that quote against your own order value and conversion rate before you say yes. (You know how I feel about knowing your numbers.) And if you’re an agency, you can run several brands from one account, copy a strong prospect list from one client to another, and choose whether outreach goes out as the brand or as you.
What it turned up when I tested it
When I first tested it, I ran searches across categories I work in. For outdoor gear alone it found 47 relevant content creators, contact details for 23 of them, plus traffic and authority data and examples of what they’d already promoted.
In about ten minutes.
By hand, that’s days. More likely a couple of weeks, squeezed in around everything else.
And the list taught me something too. You start to see which kinds of creators are active in the category, which formats they lean on and which angles they use to sell. That’s market research you’d normally pay for.
Where UpPromote fits
AffiliateFinder fills the programme. Something still has to run it.
On Shopify, that’s usually UpPromote: tracking links and codes, commission rules, payouts, and a portal your partners log into. Get that sorted first. There’s no point recruiting brilliant affiliates into a programme with no tracking, woolly terms and a payout process that relies on you remembering.
(If you’re still choosing, here’s what to consider when starting an affiliate programme for your Shopify store, and my start here guide to affiliate programmes.)
Then point AffiliateFinder at your competitors and start filling it.
A few things to get right before you hit send
- Make the offer worth their time. Look at what your competitors pay. If you’re asking someone to give you some of their attention, give them a reason. Better commission, a better landing page, a better product story.
- Start small and specific. Ten great-fit prospects with a properly personal email will beat 200 templated ones. Every time.
- Give them something to work with. Product to try, a story worth telling, decent assets. Affiliates sell what they understand.
- Track who converts, then go and find more of them. Run a lookalike search on your best performers.
- Remember the tool won’t build the relationship for you. It finds the people and handles the admin. Making them want to work with you is still your job.
If you want the bigger picture on building the programme around all this, have a gander at my affiliate strategy for ecommerce brands.
Start with three competitors
So here’s your homework.
Write down three competitors. The ones your customers mention when they’re weighing you up.
Then go and find out who’s selling for them.
Do it by hand if you like. It’s a good exercise, once. Or try AffiliateFinder.ai free for 7 days and see what turns up in ten minutes.
Then let me know who you found. I’m genuinely curious.