Disclosure: Lifetimely is a partner of mine, and the Lifetimely links on this page are partner links. If you sign up, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How this works.
Most free-shipping thresholds are a guess
Someone picks £50 because it sounds right, or because a competitor uses it. A banner goes up, average order value creeps up, and everyone calls it a win.
Then you look at what shipping actually costs you. The threshold sits below what most customers were already spending, so you’re now paying postage on orders that would have paid it themselves. Or it sits so far above a typical basket that nobody bothers, and you’ve added a banner that does nothing. Either way, you’ve never checked what the threshold leaves you per order once the label is paid for.
That’s the trouble with low order value as a target. Free shipping moves it easily. Whether it moves profit depends entirely on where you put the line.
A free-shipping threshold is a price. Set it on margin, not on a round number, and judge it on profit per order, not on order value.
You can do most of this with what’s already in your Shopify admin. The one gap is shipping cost: Shopify knows what customers paid you for delivery, but unless you buy every label through Shopify, it doesn’t know what delivery cost you. That’s where Lifetimely comes in.
What Shopify gives you to work with
Shopify‘s built-in analytics cover the order-value side well:
- Average order value over time. In Analytics, then Reports. Shopify works it out as gross sales minus discounts, divided by orders, so it leaves shipping out.
- Orders over time. Order count, average units per order and average order value, so you can see whether a change is moving basket size or just order numbers.
- Shipping labels over time and Shipping labels by order. If you buy labels through Shopify, these show label cost, and the second puts the shipping price the customer paid next to what the label cost you.
- Custom explorations. Available on all Shopify plans from Analytics, Reports, New exploration, for when the default reports don’t cut the data the way you need.
What Shopify doesn’t give you is a ready-made view of how many orders fall into each order-value band. You’ll build that yourself in step 3. It’s ten minutes in a spreadsheet.
Where I’d start
This is the order I’d work through it with any Shopify brand that wants a bigger basket without handing the margin to the courier…
1. Find out what a delivery really costs you. Not what you charge. What you pay. If you buy labels through Shopify, the Shipping labels reports give you the average label cost, and the shipping section of your Shopify bill breaks fees down by order. If you use a 3PL or another label platform, take it from their invoices. Add the packaging. You want a realistic cost per order, ideally per country or zone, because a threshold that works for UK orders can lose money on every international one.
2. Get shipping costs into your P&L with Lifetimely. This is the step most brands skip, and it’s why their margin numbers look better than they are. Lifetimely lets you bring shipping costs in several ways: integrations with ShipStation, ShipBob or Shopify Shipping to import them automatically, a Google Sheet or CSV matched to order IDs, product-specific rates, or flat rates by country. Once they’re in, shipping shows as its own line under cost of goods sold in the income statement, alongside product costs, transaction fees and handling costs. That gives you contribution margin per order with delivery properly counted, which is the number the threshold has to be set against. While you’re there, check every SKU has a product cost, or every calculation that follows will flatter you.
3. Map where your orders actually sit. Export your orders for the last few months and group them into bands of order value, say £5 or £10 wide. You’re looking for the cluster: where most orders land, and how many sit just below the level you’re considering. A threshold works by nudging people who are a little short of it to add something. If there’s nobody just short of it, there’s nobody to nudge.
4. Set the line on margin. Start a little above your most common order value, then do the maths for the customers you’re nudging. As a simple illustration: say a typical order is £42, delivery costs you £4.50, and your gross margin on products is 55%. Set the threshold at £50 and a customer who tops up from £42 to £50 adds £8 of sales, roughly £4.40 of margin, and you give up the delivery charge they’d have paid, say £4.50 if you charge at cost. That’s close to break-even on them. Meanwhile every order already over £50 that used to pay for delivery now doesn’t. Run that for your own margin, your own shipping cost and your own order bands before you pick a number. Use your own figures, not mine.
5. Set it up in Shopify. There are two ways. In Settings, then Shipping and delivery, you can give a shipping zone a rate based on order amount, with a free tier above your threshold. Leave the maximum empty on the top tier, or orders above it will hit an error at checkout. Or create a Free shipping discount under Discounts, set it as automatic, and add a minimum purchase amount. The discount route gives you more control, by country, by customer segment and by dates, and Shopify counts products towards the minimum at their discounted price, which stops a promotion pushing people over the line for free.
6. Tell people, in the cart. A threshold nobody notices is just a lower price on some orders. Show how far the customer is from it in the cart, through your theme or a cart app. If you’re working out what to suggest as the top-up, my bundles guide shows how to find what customers actually buy together.
7. Test it if you can, then judge it on profit. On the Grow plan or higher, Shopify’s Rollouts can run an Experiment on a discount, comparing a treatment against a control, which makes the free-shipping discount the testable route. If that’s not open to you, compare a few weeks before and after, and keep an eye on what else changed in that time. Either way, the verdict comes from contribution margin per order in Lifetimely, not from order value in Shopify.
Let Profit Agent keep an eye on it
Shipping costs drift. Carriers put prices up, a new zone starts selling, a heavy product takes off. On the paid plans, Lifetimely’s Profit Agent monitors your store, surfaces what needs your attention and proposes what to do, and nothing happens without your approval. It won’t set the threshold for you, but it’s a useful second pair of eyes on whether free delivery is still paying for itself. There’s more on it on my Lifetimely tool page.
What to measure
- Contribution margin per order. With shipping costs in. This is the number the whole exercise is for.
- The share of orders over the threshold. Before and after. If it barely moves, the threshold is too high or nobody can see it.
- Orders just over the line. A bump of orders landing just above the threshold is the nudge working. No bump means it isn’t.
- Conversion rate. A threshold that lifts basket size but puts people off checking out at all is a bad trade.
- Shipping cost per order. Overall and for international orders on their own.
The mistakes I see most
Setting it below the typical basket. If most customers already spend more than the threshold, you’ve just started paying their postage. It’s the most common mistake and the most expensive.
Comparing the wrong AOV. Shopify’s average order value leaves shipping out. Lifetimely’s includes shipping revenue. Both are fine, but don’t put a number from one next to a number from the other and call it a change.
One threshold for every country. Delivering abroad usually costs more. Set the threshold by zone or by market, or exclude the zones where the maths doesn’t work.
Judging it on order value. AOV is the easiest number to move and the least useful to celebrate. Profit per order is what counts.
Never revisiting it. A threshold set two carrier price rises ago is probably losing money now. Check it whenever your shipping costs change.
My verdict
The brands I’m working with right now are fighting the same battles: spend that’s crept up faster than the profit, no clear picture of how to scale, and not enough modern ecommerce know-how in the team to see where the margin is going. Free shipping is a good example. It’s one setting in Shopify, it feels like a growth lever, and most brands have never worked out what it costs them per order.
Shopify gives you the order-value side for nothing. Lifetimely is the tool I use for the cost side, because it puts shipping, product costs and fees into one P&L, so the threshold gets set on margin rather than on a hunch. It isn’t the right choice for everyone. If you buy every label through Shopify and do a modest number of orders, Shopify’s own label reports and a spreadsheet will get you most of the way. If you’re doing a few dozen orders a month, the free plan covers up to 50 orders a month, but there won’t be much data to read yet. And if you sell one high-ticket product where every order clears any sensible threshold anyway, just build delivery into the price.
For a Shopify brand with steady orders, a real shipping bill and a threshold nobody has checked in a while, it’s where I’d start. Paid plans run from $49 a month by order volume, each with a 14-day free trial, so you can check your own numbers before you commit.
Try Lifetimely free for 14 days
Related reading: How To Optimise Bundles Using Lifetimely’s Product Journey Data and How To Optimise Meta Ad Spend Using Lifetimely’s Contribution Margin and Channel Data. More guides on this problem: Low average order value.
More on this lever: The Order Value Lever: How To Optimise AOV Without Discounting.
Ian