Disclosure: Fairing is a partner of mine, and the Fairing links on this page are partner links. If you sign up, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How this works.
Why Running Out of Ad Hooks Costs You Money
Your best ad is tired. Frequency is creeping up, cost per purchase is creeping with it, and someone in the team says “we need new creative”.
So you brainstorm. Ten hooks come out of a meeting room. Most of them sound like every other brand in your category, because they came from people who already know the product inside out.
That’s the expensive bit. Every hook that flops still has to spend its way to a verdict. Run enough guesses and you’re paying Meta to tell you what your customers could have told you for free.
Because they will tell you. Ask a customer, right after they’ve paid, why they bought and what nearly stopped them, and you get the hook in their words. Not yours.
Why I Use Fairing to Find Ad Hooks
Fairing is the post-purchase survey tool I work with. Most brands know it for “How did you hear about us?” (I’ve written up how I use that for attribution). But Fairing describes its Question Stream as a way to ask how buyers heard about you, what almost stopped them buying and how likely they are to recommend you, all in one survey after checkout. Those middle answers are where the hooks live.
The bits that matter for creative:
- It asks at the right moment. On Shopify the survey sits on the thank-you and order status pages, when the reason for buying is still fresh.
- It can target who gets asked. Fairing lets you set rules by new or returning customer, location and order data. For hooks you want new customers: they’re the people your prospecting ads have to win.
- Follow-up questions are on every plan. So a vague answer can get a second question that pins it down.
- You can read it with Claude. Fairing’s MCP server connects your survey data to Claude and other AI clients. Fairing says you can dig into “Other” responses and pull verbatim quotes for a brief. That second one is exactly the job here. (It reads your data. Fairing says write access is coming later.)
- Answers can go to Klaviyo. Responses sync to customer profiles, so a hook that works in ads can be tested in email too.
More on how I use it on my Fairing tool page.
Step-by-Step: How to Turn Fairing Survey Answers Into Ad Hooks
This is the order I’d work through it with any brand whose creative has gone stale…
1. Add a “why” question after the attribution one. Keep “How did you hear about us?” first. Then ask “What made you decide to buy today?” and leave it open. Multiple choice gives you tidy charts. Open text gives you copy.
2. Add the objection question. “What nearly stopped you buying?” The answer is the doubt your ad has to kill in the first three seconds. I covered using this one on product pages in How To Optimise Product Pages Using Fairing’s “What Nearly Stopped You Buying?” Question. Same answers, different job.
3. Show both to new customers only. Returning customers already trust you. Their reasons are about loyalty, not about being won over by a stranger in a feed.
4. Let it run before you read it. A handful of answers is a handful of opinions. Wait until you’ve got enough that the same reasons keep turning up.
5. Sort the answers into themes. Connect Fairing’s MCP to Claude and ask it to group the answers, or do it from your data by hand. You’re looking for the five or six reasons that come up again and again: the gift that solved a problem, the ingredient someone was hunting for, the size that finally fit.
6. Pull the exact words. For each theme, take the three best verbatim quotes. Don’t polish them. “I was sick of mugs that go cold” beats “Long-lasting thermal performance” every time, because it’s how a real person talks.
7. Write one hook per theme. Open the ad with the customer’s line, or the objection answered head-on. Keep the body and the offer the same across the test, so the hook is the only thing that changes.
8. Test, then go back to the survey. Run the hooks against your current best ad. Keep the winners, retire the losers, and next month pull fresh themes. The survey keeps filling up while you test, so you never go back to an empty brainstorm.
Claude Prompts for Pulling Hooks From Your Fairing Data
If you’ve got Fairing’s MCP connected to Claude, ask these straight out. If not, the same questions work on an export of your answers.
“From the last 60 days of answers to ‘What made you decide to buy today?’, from new customers only, group the answers into the six most common reasons. Give the share of answers for each and three verbatim quotes.”
“List the most common answers to ‘What nearly stopped you buying?’ For each one, quote two customers word for word and suggest a one-line ad hook that answers the doubt.”
“Compare the reasons for buying given by customers who heard about us on Instagram with those who heard about us from a friend. What’s different?”
“Find phrases customers use that never appear on our website or in our ads. Quote them exactly.”
That last one is my favourite. It finds the words your customers use that your team never would.
What to Measure to Judge Your Survey-Led Ad Hooks
- Hook rate. The share of people who watch past the first few seconds of a video. This is the hook’s job, so judge it on this first.
- Click-through rate. A hook that stops the scroll but sends nobody to the site is entertainment, not advertising.
- Cost per purchase against your current best ad. Same audience, same budget, same offer. Only the hook changes.
- Hit rate. Of the hooks you test, how many beat your control? If survey-led hooks win more often than the brainstormed ones, you’ve got your answer on where creative should start.
- The survey itself, next month. If a hook works, do more new customers start giving that reason for buying? It’s a nice check that the ad is bringing in the people you meant it to.
Common Mistakes When Turning Survey Answers Into Ad Creative
Polishing the words. The whole point is the customer’s language. The minute a copywriter tidies “it actually fits my massive feet” into something on-brand, you’ve lost the hook.
Only using multiple choice. Tick boxes tell you which reason is most common. They can’t give you a line to put in an ad.
Asking returning customers. Their reasons are real, but they’re not the reasons a stranger needs to hear.
Chasing the loudest single answer. One brilliant quote is tempting. If nobody else says anything like it, it’s a one-off, not a theme.
Testing ten hooks at once on a small budget. None of them gets enough spend to prove anything. Two or three at a time against your control is plenty. And you probably need fewer variations than you think (I wrote about that in Does Meta Really Need Massive Creative Volume After Andromeda?).
My Verdict: When Fairing Is the Right Tool for Finding Ad Hooks
The brands I’m working with right now are fighting the same battles: ad spend that’s crept up without the profit to match, no clear view of how to scale, and not enough modern ecommerce know-how in the team to sort it. Not enough creative sits right in the middle. When the ads go stale, costs rise, and the usual fix is more guessing. Asking the people who just bought is quicker, cheaper and a lot more honest.
It isn’t the right choice for everyone. If you’re doing a handful of orders a month, you won’t have enough answers to spot themes yet, although the free plan (up to 200 orders a month) is a sensible way to start collecting. Paid plans start at $49 a month, priced by order volume, with a 14-day free trial. If you already run Fairing for attribution, this is one more question, not a new tool. And if your problem is making creative fast rather than knowing what to say, a survey won’t shoot the video for you: you need production help as well.
For a Shopify brand spending on Meta and running out of things to say, though, it’s where I’d start. Ask why they bought. Ask what nearly stopped them. Then put their words in your ads and see what happens. Let me know how you get on.
Related reading: How To Optimise Marketing Attribution Using Fairing’s “Where Did You Hear About Us?” Survey and Does Meta Really Need Massive Creative Volume After Andromeda? (Short Answer: No). More guides on this problem: Not enough ad creative.
More on this lever: The Traffic Lever: How To Optimise Traffic Without Paying More For Every Visitor.
Ian