Everyone (and I mean EVERYONE!) is talking about how to get better at AI.
What if the real competitive edge in the next stage of your growth is getting better at being human?
The Situation: How Ecommerce Brands Are Rushing Into AI and What’s Getting Lost
Open any ecommerce newsletter, attend any event, scroll any founder community and the message is consistent: learn the tools, write better prompts, automate the workflows, build the agents.
AI adoption has become the benchmark for how serious you are about growth. And it is serious. The brands doing it well are compressing what used to take weeks into hours. They are testing more, producing more, moving faster. The operational case is not in question.
Something, more important, is getting lost in the rush to adopt.
The brands pull aheading ahead in the growth stakes aren’t necessarily the ones with the most sophisticated AI workflows. They are the ones who have sharpened something more fundamental: a clarity about their customer, their positioning, and the meaning behind their product that no tool can generate for them.
They are using AI better because they are being more human first.
The Misunderstanding: Treating AI as a Tools Problem Instead of a Customer Insight Problem
Most founders currently working through AI adoption are treating it as a capability problem;
- If I learn more about the tools, I will get more out of them, right?
- If I build better workflows, I can scale faster, right?
- If I use AI across more of the business, I will compound the gains, right?
That logic is not wrong. But it is incomplete.
AI amplifies what you put in. If the inputs are thin, the outputs are thin. If your understanding of your customer is shallow, AI will help you produce shallow content at scale. If your brand voice is vague, AI will make it vaguer. If your value proposition is a collection of features rather than a clear expression of who you serve and why it matters, AI will reproduce that confusion across every channel you operate.
The problem is not the tool. The problem is the raw material you are feeding it.
AI amplifies what you put in. Thin inputs produce thin outputs, faster and at greater scale.
I see this in the content brands are producing. More volume, less signal. More structured, less human. More consistent, less memorable. The machine is running. But it is running on empty.
If you look at the content, copy, and customer communications you produced in the last 90 days, how much of it reflects a genuine understanding of how your customers think and feel? And how much of it was shaped by what the AI made easy to produce?
What Is Actually Happening: Two Very Different Paths to AI Adoption in Ecommerce
There is a version of AI adoption that makes you faster at doing the wrong things. You then spend time over analysing where it all went wrong and mopping up mistakes can be very costly (“we need to throw more budget into ads…”)
There is another version that makes you much more effective at doing the right things. The difference sits entirely in the quality of human thinking you bring to it.
Are the brands building sustainable competitive advantage the ones with the longest list of automations? Rarely. They’re those who are invested in customer understanding and used that understanding to configure everything else. To become a brand less ordinary.
Real customer insight is still hard work. It’s time consuming;
- Creating Post-purchase surveys that are asking the right questions.
- Review mining that looks beyond ratings.
- Customer interviews that go beneath stated preferences.
A genuine understanding of the hesitations, language, motivations, and emotional context around the purchase. None of that comes from a prompt. It comes from deliberate, human-led investigation.
When you have all that in place, AI becomes genuinely powerful. Because AI tools are getting better? No because the signal quality feeding them is higher.
- The copy is better because it uses real customer language.
- The content strategy is better because it addresses real upstream questions.
- The retention architecture is better because it reflects how customers actually use the product and what they need to come back.
This is the version of AI adoption most founders are not talking about. Certainly not the version that I’m seeing the latest batch of AI AgEnCiEs shouting about.
The brands winning are the ones feeding AI automations with better human thinking.
When was the last time I sat with unfiltered customer feedback and used it to change something material in how you communicate, position, or sell? Not to fix a complaint. But to learn something you did not already know.
The Reframe: Treat AI as an Amplifier of Deep Customer Understanding, Not a Replacement
Think of AI as a machine that multiplies what you give it.
The operator’s job, your job, isn’t to be the master of the machine. It is to improve the quality of the inputs.
That means doing things AI genuinely cannot do. It means talking to your customers and listening carefully. It means spending time in your reviews (use those FB comments to your advantage!!) your support tickets, your survey data. It means finding the language real people use to describe the problem your product solves. It means understanding the moment in someone’s life when your product becomes relevant to them.
None of that requires a better prompt. It requires a willingness to be curious about actual people rather than modelled personas.
Final question before I wrap up, are you spending more time this year learning how to prompt AI than the time you set aside to learn how your customers think? Where is the balance, and is it right?
Are You Spending More Time Learning AI Prompts Than Understanding Your Customers?
The ecommerce brands I have seen scale consistently well 28 years share something in common. I will write a book about this one day. It is very rarely about the tools they use, it’s the quality of their understanding. They know their customer with an unusual depth. That’s how they build commuity around their products. They know what they stand for with unusual clarity. They know the gap between where a customer is and where the product takes them.
AI does not change that principle. If anything, it sharpens the stakes around it.
Surely if the job of AI is to make everyone faster, the competitive edge shifts even further toward the quality of thinking behind the speed. The brand with genuine insight, running on good tools, will compound its advantage over the brand running on generic thinking and better prompts.
Okay, so one final question to you, the question rummaging around with, is not how much more AI can I add. It is how much better do I understand the people I am trying to serve using AI? That understanding, built deliberately and refreshed consistently, is the input that makes everything else work harder.
The machine is important. What you put into it is more important still.