How we can work together →

Shopify Consultant

Plan and scale growth for your Shopify store

Fractional Ecommerce Director

Ongoing leadership for next-stage ecommerce growth

Ecommerce Consultant

Hired to solve specific growth challenges

Ecommerce Coaching

1-2-1 mentoring for founders and ecommerce leaders

Conversion Strategy

How to convert more visitors into buyers

Retention Strategy

Grow your ecommerce business on repeat

SEO & GEO Consultant

Become the answer in Google and AI search

1-Day Ecommerce Growth Blueprint

One focused day to map your next stage of growth

Replatform to Shopify

Build your growth machine right from day one

Testimonials

What founders say about working together

Not sure which fits? Let’s talk it through.

“Working with Ian is probably the best thing that has happened to us in the last 6 years.”

Rivki Stoll · Private White VC

Data →

Ecomonomics

The numbers behind your ecommerce growth

Attribution and measurement

Know what is really driving your sales

Technology →

Tools and martech

The tools that power modern ecommerce growth

SEO and AI visibility

Get found in search and in AI answers

Affiliates and partnerships

Collaborations, partnerships and affiliate programmes

Human touch →

Brand and positioning

The insight and stories that make your brand matter

Retention and subscriptions

Growing profitable repeat business

Content and community

Copy, stories and community that build connection

New lessons every weekday · 100s of articles, written by me, not a robot

Explore all growth lessons →

How To Optimise Product Pages Using Fairing’s “What Nearly Stopped You Buying?” Question

Disclosure: Fairing is a partner of mine, and the Fairing links on this page are partner links. If you sign up, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. How this works.

Why Guessing at Product Page Objections Costs You Sales

Most product page changes start with an opinion. Someone thinks the photos need work, someone else wants more reviews higher up, the agency suggests a new trust badge. The page gets changed, and nobody ever asked the people who actually bought what made them pause.

That’s expensive. Every visitor on a product page has already cost you money to get there. If the thing that stops people buying is a question about delivery, sizing or returns, and you spend the month rewriting the product description, you’ve paid for the traffic and fixed the wrong thing.

Your buyers know what nearly put them off. They got over it, which makes them the best people to ask, because they can tell you what the people who left didn’t get past. So ask them, right after they’ve paid: what nearly stopped you buying today?

Why Use Fairing to Ask “What Nearly Stopped You Buying?”

Fairing is the post-purchase survey tool I work with. Most brands know it for the “How did you hear about us?” question, but Fairing describes itself as asking buyers how they found you, why they bought and what almost stopped them, right after checkout. Same tool, same placement, a different question.

The bits that matter for this job:

  • It asks at the right moment. Surveys sit on the Shopify thank you and order status pages, when the purchase is fresh and people are happy to give you a few seconds.
  • Follow-up questions. Fairing supports follow-ups and conditional logic, so an answer like “Price” or “Delivery” can lead to a second question that gets to the detail.
  • Targeting. Its Shopify App Store listing covers targeting by new versus returning customers, by product purchased and by geography. For this question, that’s the important bit: a first-time buyer’s hesitation is what your product page needs to answer.
  • The answers go where you work. Responses can sync to Klaviyo, Google Sheets and Shopify orders, and Fairing lists GA4 among its integrations. It also has an MCP server (in beta on the App Store listing), so you can ask Claude about the answers directly.

More on how I use it on my Fairing tool page.

Step-by-Step: How to Turn Buyer Hesitation Into Product Page Fixes

This is the order I’d work through it with any brand whose product pages get the traffic but not the orders…

1. Ask first-time buyers only. Returning customers already trust you, so what nearly stopped them tells you little about your product page. Use Fairing’s new versus returning targeting so the question goes to first orders.

2. Keep the question plain. “What nearly stopped you buying today?” One question, in plain English. Fairing’s own list of expert questions includes almost exactly this one, from the Shopify agency Barrel, filed under conversion rate optimisation.

3. Give a short list of answers, plus “Nothing”. Price, delivery cost or time, not sure about size or fit, not sure it would work for me, returns, not sure about the brand, and “Nothing, I was ready to buy”. Six or seven options at most. Make sure people have a way to say it in their own words too, because the exact wording is what you’ll end up putting on the page.

4. Add a follow-up where you can act on it. “Delivery” on its own is a hint. A follow-up asking whether it was the cost, the speed or not knowing when it would arrive tells you which block to change.

5. Split by product. If you sell more than one type of product, the objections will differ. Fairing can target by product purchased, so you can run the question on your biggest sellers, or read answers product by product.

6. Map the answers to the page. Take the top three objections for a product and open its page on your phone. Where does the page answer each one? How far down? If the answer is “in the FAQ, below the reviews”, you’ve found your first change. I wrote about laying the page out around these answers in How To Optimise Product Page Layouts Using Shopify’s Theme Editor and Shoplift.

7. Fix one objection at a time, and test it. Move the delivery information next to the button. Add a size guide where people decide, not in the footer. Put the returns policy in a sentence near the price. One change per test, so you know what did it.

8. Keep asking. Once a fix lands, that answer should come up less. Watch the share of each objection month by month. When the top one drops, move to the next.

Questions to Ask Once the Answers Are Coming In

If you’ve got Fairing’s MCP connected to Claude, ask these straight out. If not, the same questions work from an export.

“For the last 60 days, show the answers to ‘What nearly stopped you buying today?’ for first-time customers, ranked by share of responses.”

“Break those answers down by the product purchased. Which product has the most customers mentioning delivery or sizing?”

“Summarise the written answers into themes and pull out the exact phrases customers use most often.”

“Compare this month’s answers with last month’s. Which objection has gone up, and which has gone down?”

What to Measure to Judge Whether It Worked

  • Share of each objection. The main signal. If you fixed the delivery information, “delivery” answers should fall.
  • Share of “Nothing”. More first-time buyers saying nothing nearly stopped them means the page is answering more questions before they ask.
  • Response rate. If too few people answer, you’re acting on a handful of opinions. Keep it to one question plus a follow-up.
  • Product page conversion rate and revenue per visitor. The survey tells you what to fix. These tell you whether the fix made money. Judge them against a control, not just before and after.

Common Mistakes Brands Make With Hesitation Questions

Asking everyone. Returning customers dilute the answers. The question is about the first-time decision, so ask the first-time buyer.

Forgetting who you’re asking. These are people who bought. They got past the objection. The people who left had the same doubts, or bigger ones. Treat the answers as the most common objections, not the complete list, and check them against your support inbox and reviews.

Writing the answer list from your own assumptions. If your options are all about price, every answer will be about price. Start broad, read what people write, and update the list.

Fixing it with copy alone. Sometimes the objection is real. If delivery is slow or returns cost money, a better sentence won’t fix that. Take it to whoever owns the offer.

Leaving the answers in a dashboard. If nobody reads them until the quarterly review, nothing changes. Make them part of the monthly product page review, and send them to Klaviyo so your post-purchase flows can use them.

My Verdict: When Fairing Is the Right Tool for Finding Product Page Objections

The brands I’m working with right now are fighting the same battles: too much going into ads to send traffic to pages that don’t convert it, no clear view of what to change to scale, and not enough modern ecommerce know-how in the team to know where to start. Not knowing why customers buy, or nearly don’t, sits under all three. You can’t fix an objection you’ve never heard.

One question on the thank you page gives you a ranked list of the reasons people hesitate, in their words, for each product. That’s a better product page brief than any best-practice checklist.

It isn’t the right choice for everyone. If you’re doing a handful of orders a month, you won’t get enough answers to see a pattern for a while, although Fairing’s free plan (up to 200 orders a month, no credit card needed) is a sensible way to start collecting. Paid plans start at $49 a month, with a 14-day free trial. If you already run Fairing for attribution, think about where this question sits: asking too much on one page costs you responses, so I’d start with one question plus a follow-up and target it carefully. And if your product pages barely get traffic, the problem is further up the funnel, not here.

For a Shopify brand with real traffic and product pages that aren’t pulling their weight, though, it’s where I’d start. Ask the question, read the answers, and fix the objection that comes up most. Let me know how you get on.

Try Fairing free

Related reading: How To Optimise Marketing Attribution Using Fairing’s “Where Did You Hear About Us?” Survey and Stop Guessing. Start Knowing. More guides on this problem: Not knowing why customers buy.

More on this lever: The Conversion Lever: How To Optimise Conversion Rate Using Real Customer Data.

Ian


Free book

Liked this? There are 30 more where that came from.

Make What You Make Matter. 30 lessons in ecommerce growth, written on the shop floor long before AI showed up. Read every chapter free, or take the PDF with you.

Read the book freeGet the PDF

Every Monday at 9am

Ecommerce Growth Lessons

A weekly newsletter written for founders to help solve the day-to-day challenges faced when growing and scaling a thriving ecommerce business.

Free. Every Monday at 9am. Unsubscribe any time.

Ian Rhodes

Written by EcommerceGrowth.com Founder – Ian Rhodes

Helping founders solve the day-to-day challenges faced when growing and scaling a thriving ecommerce business.

Independent Ecommerce Consultant & Coach and author of Make What You Make Matter, with 28 years of ecommerce leadership and 750+ brands worked with. Hired to prioritise and lead the work that delivers next stage growth.

More Ecommerce Growth Lessons and How-To Guides