How we can work together →

Shopify Consultant

Plan and scale growth for your Shopify store

Fractional Ecommerce Director

Ongoing leadership for next-stage ecommerce growth

Ecommerce Consultant

Hired to solve specific growth challenges

Ecommerce Coaching

1-2-1 mentoring for founders and ecommerce leaders

Conversion Strategy

How to convert more visitors into buyers

Retention Strategy

Grow your ecommerce business on repeat

SEO & GEO Consultant

Become the answer in Google and AI search

1-Day Ecommerce Growth Blueprint

One focused day to map your next stage of growth

Replatform to Shopify

Build your growth machine right from day one

Testimonials

What founders say about working together

Not sure which fits? Let’s talk it through.

“Working with Ian is probably the best thing that has happened to us in the last 6 years.”

Rivki Stoll · Private White VC

Data →

Ecomonomics

The numbers behind your ecommerce growth

Attribution and measurement

Know what is really driving your sales

Technology →

Tools and martech

The tools that power modern ecommerce growth

SEO and AI visibility

Get found in search and in AI answers

Affiliates and partnerships

Collaborations, partnerships and affiliate programmes

Human touch →

Brand and positioning

The insight and stories that make your brand matter

Retention and subscriptions

Growing profitable repeat business

Content and community

Copy, stories and community that build connection

New lessons every weekday · 100s of articles, written by me, not a robot

Explore all growth lessons →

,

How To Optimise Your Welcome Flow Using Klaviyo Sign-Up Form Data

Why a Welcome Flow That Ignores the Form Costs You Subscribers and Sales

Most welcome flows are built once and left alone. Someone sets up a popup, picks a discount, plugs in the pre-built three-email series and moves on. Months later the popup is still showing, the emails are still sending, and nobody can tell you whether either is doing its job.

That’s expensive. Every visitor who sees your sign-up form has already cost you money to get to the site. If the form converts poorly, you’re paying for traffic you never get to talk to again. If the form converts well but the welcome flow treats everyone the same, you’re giving away a discount to people who would have bought anyway and saying nothing useful to the ones who wouldn’t.

The fix is to treat the form and the flow as one thing. The form decides who joins and what they were promised. The flow should pick up exactly where the form left off. Klaviyo gives you the data to join the two up, if you go and look at it.

Why Use Klaviyo’s Sign-Up Form Data for This

Klaviyo is the email platform I work with and the one I recommend. If your forms and your welcome flow both live in Klaviyo, the data you need is already sitting in one place. The bits that matter for this job:

  • Form analytics. Each form shows views, submits and submit rate, plus total revenue, orders and average order value. Klaviyo’s help centre is clear that submit rate is total submits divided by total views, so it counts every submit, not unique people.
  • Breakdowns that matter. The additional reports split views, submits, submit rate and revenue by device (desktop or mobile) and by UTM source, medium and campaign. Multi-step forms also get a step-by-step funnel.
  • Form revenue. Klaviyo links orders to a form submission inside a lookback window you choose, from 15 minutes up to 24 hours (2 hours by default). It only works for visitors Klaviyo can identify, and it’s tracked separately from email revenue, so don’t add the two together.
  • A/B testing. You can test a form’s offer, timing, teaser, copy and layout, with the winner picked automatically or by you. Results per variation include unique views, unique submits, submit rate, orders, AOV and revenue.
  • Hidden fields. A form can write a profile property when someone submits (Klaviyo’s own example is an “Offer” property), and the flow can split on it. That’s the link between the form and the flow.

More on how I use it on my Klaviyo tool page.

Step-by-Step: How to Rebuild Your Welcome Flow Around Your Form Data

This is the order I’d work through it with any brand that’s getting traffic but not building the list it should…

1. Start with the form, not the emails. Open Sign-up forms and look at the list view. Klaviyo shows each form’s engagement rate and revenue over the last 30 days, with a benchmark status from Poor to Excellent against similar accounts. Klaviyo’s own guidance is to aim for about 3% or higher on a popup or flyout. If your main form sits well below that, fix the form first. A better welcome flow can’t help people who never joined.

2. Split it by device. In the form’s analytics, open the additional reports and compare desktop with mobile. If most of your traffic is on a phone, a form designed on a laptop may not be fit for it. If mobile submit rate is much lower, that’s your first change: shorter copy, a smaller form, a clear way to close it.

3. Split it by traffic source. Use the UTM breakdown. People arriving from a paid social ad, from Google and from an influencer post are in different places. If one source signs up at half the rate of the others, either the form or the landing page isn’t matching what that ad promised.

4. Check where multi-step forms lose people. If you ask for email and then phone number, the step funnel shows how many drop off at each step. Klaviyo counts the submit on whichever step asks for email or phone first, so you still keep the email. Just don’t let a second step you don’t need cost you the first.

5. Test the offer, and tag it. Set up an A/B test on the form, one variable at a time. The offer is usually the one worth testing first: 10% off against free shipping, for example. In each variation, add a hidden field on the submit button that sets a profile property such as Offer to that variation’s offer. Keep both variations on the same list.

6. Make the flow deliver what the form promised. Trigger the welcome flow on “Added to list” for that list. Klaviyo’s help centre shows how to filter it to one form using the form’s ID (the $consent_form_id profile property), and how to exclude those subscribers from any other welcome flow on the same list. Then add a conditional split on the Offer property, so each person’s first email shows the offer they signed up for. One catch: the Offer property only appears in the split’s dropdown after you’ve filled the form in yourself as a test, so do that first, and check both variations send the right value.

7. Put the incentive in the first email. Klaviyo recommends it, and it’s right. Someone who just gave you their email for a code wants the code now, not in three days.

8. Split on whether they’ve bought. Add a conditional split on “Placed Order at least once since starting this flow”. People who’ve already used the code don’t need reminders about it. They need a reason to come back, which is where your post-purchase emails take over. People who haven’t bought get the reminder and the reasons to trust you. A second split on “Placed Order at least once over all time” stops existing customers who join the list being treated as strangers.

9. Change one thing at a time, then leave it. Klaviyo’s advice is not to change test settings mid-test, and you can’t edit variations while a test is live. Let it run until it picks a winner, then move on to the next variable.

What to Measure to Judge Whether It Worked

  • Submit rate, by device and source. The main measure of whether you’re capturing enough people. Compare like with like: mobile with mobile, the same source month on month.
  • Revenue per variation. A form that gets more sign-ups with a bigger discount isn’t necessarily better. Look at orders, AOV and revenue on the A/B test results, not just submit rate.
  • First-order rate from the welcome flow. How many new subscribers place a first order while they’re in the flow. That’s the job the flow exists to do.
  • Margin on those first orders. A welcome discount is a cost. If the winning offer brings in more orders at a lower margin, check the maths before you call it the winner.

Common Mistakes Brands Make With Sign-Up Forms and Welcome Flows

Judging the form on submit rate alone. The easiest way to double sign-ups is to double the discount. That doesn’t mean you’ve made more money. Use the revenue figures alongside submit rate.

Reading form revenue as email revenue. Klaviyo tracks them separately, with different rules, and the figures can differ. Treat the form’s revenue as a guide to which form performs better, not as an extra line of income.

Promising one thing and sending another. If the form says free shipping and the first email says 10% off, you’ve lost trust in the first message. Tag the offer on the form and split on it in the flow.

Testing everything at once. New copy, new timing and a new offer in one variation tells you nothing about which change mattered.

Leaving the flow running for buyers. Sending a “don’t forget your code” email to someone who used it yesterday is a waste of a send and a little embarrassing. Split on Placed Order.

My Verdict: When Klaviyo’s Form Data Is the Right Way to Optimise a Welcome Flow

The brands I’m working with right now are fighting the same battles: too much going into ads, no clear view of how to scale without spending more, and not enough modern ecommerce know-how in the team to know where to look first. A sign-up form that leaks visitors, feeding a welcome flow that treats everyone the same, makes all three worse. You’ve paid for the visit and got nothing to show for it.

If your forms and flows are already in Klaviyo, this is work you can do this week without buying anything. Read the form by device and source, test the offer, tag it, and make the first email deliver it.

It isn’t the right approach for everyone. If your forms run through a separate popup tool, the form data lives there, not in Klaviyo, and you’ll need to check what that tool passes across before you can split on it. I’ve written about why I use OptiMonk when Klaviyo’s form builder isn’t enough. If you only get a trickle of sign-ups, an A/B test will take a long time to say anything, so fix the obvious problems on mobile first. And if your traffic is low, the problem is further up the funnel, not in the form.

For a Shopify brand with steady traffic and a list that isn’t growing as it should, though, it’s where I’d start. Let me know how you get on.

Related reading: How To Optimise Post-Purchase Klaviyo Flows Using Post-Purchase Surveys and How To Optimise Post-Purchase Emails Using Klaviyo’s Predicted Next Order Date. More guides on this problem: Not capturing enough subscribers.

More on this lever: The Conversion Lever: How To Optimise Conversion Rate Using Real Customer Data.

Ian


Free book

Liked this? There are 30 more where that came from.

Make What You Make Matter. 30 lessons in ecommerce growth, written on the shop floor long before AI showed up. Read every chapter free, or take the PDF with you.

Read the book freeGet the PDF

Every Monday at 9am

Ecommerce Growth Lessons

A weekly newsletter written for founders to help solve the day-to-day challenges faced when growing and scaling a thriving ecommerce business.

Free. Every Monday at 9am. Unsubscribe any time.

Ian Rhodes

Written by EcommerceGrowth.com Founder – Ian Rhodes

Helping founders solve the day-to-day challenges faced when growing and scaling a thriving ecommerce business.

Independent Ecommerce Consultant & Coach and author of Make What You Make Matter, with 28 years of ecommerce leadership and 750+ brands worked with. Hired to prioritise and lead the work that delivers next stage growth.

More Ecommerce Growth Lessons and How-To Guides